Treatise Mapping
Map · Book 2: Of the Passions · Part 1: Of Pride and Humility · T 2.1.11 Of the love of fame

T 2.1.11.8

SBN 319-20 · cited directly by 6 papers, reached by 2 more through page or section ranges

What is principally remarkable in this whole affair is the strong confirmation these phænomena give to the foregoing system concerning the understanding, and consequently to the present one concerning the passions; since these are analogous to each other. 'Tis indeed evident, that when we sympathize with the passions and sentiments of others, these movements appear at first in our mind as mere ideas, and are conceiv'd to belong to another person, as we conceive any other matter of fact. 'Tis also evident, that the ideas of the affections of others are converted into the very impressions they represent, and that the passions arise in conformity to the images we form of them. All this is an object of the plainest experience, and depends not on any hypothesis of |philosophy. That science can only be admitted to explain the phænomena; tho' at the same time it must be confest, they are so clear of themselves, that there is but little occasion to employ it. For besides the relation of cause and effect, by which we are convinc'd of the reality of the passion, with which we sympathize; besides this, I say, we must be assisted by the relations of resemblance and contiguity, in order to feel the sympathy in its full perfection. And since these relations can entirely convert an idea into an impression, and convey the vivacity of the latter into the former, so perfectly as to lose nothing of it in the transition, we may easily conceive how the relation of cause and effect alone, may serve to strengthen and inliven an idea. In sympathy there is an evident conversion of an idea into an impression. This conversion arises from the relation of objects to ourself. Ourself is always intimately present to us. Let us compare all these circumstances, and we shall find, that sympathy is exactly correspondent to the operations of our understanding; and even contains something more surprising and extraordinary.

Who cites it

6 of 8 papers cite this paragraph directly; the rest reach it through a page or section range. Snippets are the words around each citation.

PaperCited asContext
Mijuskovic 1971(p. 320)
T 2.1.11 (2 paragraphs)
Checked by model
…chnical, private, or self-referential. For as he makes quite clear only three pages later (p. 320) we can just as read…
Ashley 1974
focused
(320)
T 2.1.11 (2 paragraphs)
Checked by model
…ises from the relation of objects to ourself. Ourself is always intimately present to us. (320) ## and: (3) 'Tis …
Spector 1998THN 2.1.11.8
this paragraph
Citation pattern
… development as an educated person?) !5THN 2.1.2.2, p. 277. 16See THN 2.1.11.4, p. 317; THN 2.1.11.8, p. 320; THN 2.2.1.…
Strawson 20112.1.11.8
this paragraph
Citation pattern
…everymomentconscious'(340/2.2.2.17),orsaysthat'ourselfi salwaysintimatelypresenttous'(320/2.1.11.8);butreallythere'sno…
2.1.11.8
this paragraph
Citation pattern
…se,andwhateverthetruthis,'forallthatIamstillsomething'(1641:18 ). 317/2.1.11.4;seealso320/2.1.11.8:'ourselfisalwaysint…
2.1.11.8
this paragraph
Citation pattern
…)areveryclosetoHu me'sownpublishedviewsinBooks2and3oftheTreatise(seee.g.317/2.1.11.4;320 /2.1.11.8;339-40/2.2.2.15-16;…
Strawson 20122.1.11.8
this paragraph
Citation pattern
…n published views in Books 2 and 3 of the Treatise (see, for example, THN 2.1.11.4 / 317; 2.1.11.8 / 320; 2.2.2.15-16 …
Greco 2015T 2.1.11.8
this paragraph
Citation pattern
… Treatise Hume repeats various times that "[o]urself is always intimately present to us" (T 2.1.11.8/SBN 320). 4 But how…
T 2.1.11
T 2.1.11 (21 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…ecome objects of each other's moral evaluations, thanks to the principle of sympathy (see T 2.1.11; T 3.3.2). In this …
Penelhum 1992Treatise 2.1.11
T 2.1.11 (21 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…g for my concern for others. This of course is true; but when Hume first introduces it in Treatise 2.1.11, he uses it as a "s…
Mcintyre 2009T 2.1.11.2-8
T 2.1.11 (7 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…, the operation of sympathy allows us to share (and thus to know) the feelings of others (T 2.1.11.2-8). The basic functio…