Treatise Mapping
Map · Book 1: Of the Understanding · Part 4: Of the Sceptical and other systems of philosophy · T 1.4.5 Of the immateriality of the soul

T 1.4.5.5

SBN 233 · cited directly by 16 papers, reached by 9 more through page or section ranges

If instead of answering these questions, any one shou'd evade the difficulty, by saying, that the definition of a substance is something which may exist by itself; and that this definition ought to satisfy us: Shou'd this be said, I shou'd observe, that this definition agrees to every thing, that can possibly be conceiv'd; and never will serve to distinguish substance from accident, or the soul from its perceptions. For thus I reason. Whatever is clearly conceiv'd may exist; and whatever is clearly conceiv'd, after any manner, may exist after the same manner. This is one principle, which has been already acknowledg'd. Again, every thing, which is different, is distinguishable, and every thing which is distinguishable, is separable by the imagination. This is another principle. My conclusion from both is, that since all our perceptions are different from each other, and from every thing else in the universe, they are also distinct and separable, and may be consider'd as separately existent, and may exist separately, and have no need of any thing else to support their existence. They are, therefore, substances, as far as this definition explains a substance.

Who cites it

16 of 25 papers cite this paragraph directly; the rest reach it through a page or section range. Snippets are the words around each citation.

PaperCited asContext
Flage 1984(T, 233)
T 1.4.5 (3 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
… such a description will not allow one to distinguish a substance from its putative modes (T, 233), and (3) one has no…
Humber 1995
focused
(Treatise, 233)
T 1.4.5 (3 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…9 Thus, as Fogelin recognizes (Interpretations, 88), if we define 'substance'as Hume does (Treatise, 233) as 'something which…
Winkler 2000
focused
(T 233)
T 1.4.5 (3 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…e has no notion at all of substance, or no notion that distinguishes it from a perception (T 233). A reader of Locke …
Inukai 2007
focused
T 1.4.5.5
this paragraph
Citation pattern
…ay exist by itself," individual perceptions are substances; they can exist by themselves (T 1.4.5.5, SBN 233). Percepti…
Kail 2007
focused
T 1.4.5.5
this paragraph
Citation pattern
…n of the substance construed in that traditional way as 'that which may exist by itself' (T 1.4.5.5; SBN 233). There ar…
T 1.4.5.5
this paragraph
Citation pattern
…tence. They are, therefore, substances, as far as this definition explains a substance. (T 1.4.5.5; SBN 233) So we ha…
Ainslie 2008
focused
T 1.4.5.5
this paragraph
Citation pattern
…ce as that which can exist in its own right, perceptions should be counted as substances (T 1.4.5.5). The second princi…
Loeb 2009(T p. 233)
T 1.4.5 (3 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…lizes that the conceivability, and hence pos sibility, of perceptions existing separately (T p. 233) seems at odds with …
Mcintyre 20091.4.5
T 1.4.5 (42 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…ositions Collins had defended found a congenial home in Hume's Treatise. ## ii. treatise 1.4.5 and hume's account …
Treatise 1.4.5
T 1.4.5 (42 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…d hume's account of the self Hume's extended account of the nature of the self begins in Treatise 1.4.5, "Of the immaterial…
1.4.5
T 1.4.5 (42 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
… the central questions debated by Clarke and Collins. Of course, even before they reached 1.4.5, readers of the Tre…
Treatise 1.4.5
T 1.4.5 (42 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…endow'd with a perfect simplicity and identity" (T 1.4.2.39). Hume's opening argument in Treatise 1.4.5 continues the criti…
T 1.4.5.2, 5-6
T 1.4.5 (3 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
… "Whether perceptions inhere in a material or immaterial substance" is devoid of meaning (T 1.4.5.2, 5-6). 15 Clarke, Works…
Treatise 1.4.5
T 1.4.5 (42 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…e of perceptions is no obstacle to their standing in causal relations to each other. Thus Treatise 1.4.5 ends having establi…
Treatise 1.4.5
T 1.4.5 (42 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…em of personal identity can therefore be summed up in the following way: the arguments of Treatise 1.4.5 show that the mind …
Treatise 1.4.5
T 1.4.5 (42 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…reason can give of the material world." 24 This sentence refers to the first paragraph of Treatise 1.4.5, Of the immateriali…
Treatise 1.4.5
T 1.4.5 (42 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…bjects with continued and independent existence. The account of the intellectual world in Treatise 1.4.5, Of the immateriali…
1.4.5
T 1.4.5 (42 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…d is nothing but perceptions, without an underlying substance. There is no need, then, in 1.4.5 to posit a feigned …
1.4.5
T 1.4.5 (42 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
… feigned "double existence" resulting from adherence to two contrary principles. In fact, 1.4.5 presents a clever a…
1.4.5
T 1.4.5 (42 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…T 1.4.6.19-20). This progression is the natural development of the position arrived at in 1.4.5, namely, that there…
1.4.5
T 1.4.5 (42 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…re, and hence that the mind can be nothing but perceptions and their causal relations. In 1.4.5 and 1.4.6 Hume neve…
1.4.5
T 1.4.5 (42 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…. Initially, therefore, there did not appear to be a problem with the account embedded in 1.4.5 and 1.4.6. Unfortu…
Treatise 1.4.5-6
T 1.4.5.1 to T 1.4.6.6 n50 (66 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…ions indicated that he had lost his confidence that philosophical arguments like those in Treatise 1.4.5-6 could counterbalanc…
T 1.4.5-6
T 1.4.5.1 to T 1.4.6.6 n50 (66 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…ovides examples of the persistence of many of the main tenets Hume sought to establish in T 1.4.5-6, even in passages n…
T 1.4.5-6
T 1.4.5.1 to T 1.4.6.6 n50 (66 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…gument of this section of the Enquiry supports many of the conclusions Hume argued for in T 1.4.5-6. Everything we know…
Garrett 2010T 1.4.5
T 1.4.5 (42 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…bstance, first offered in the section of the Treatise "Of the immateriality of the soul" (T 1.4.5) but partly repeate…
T 1.4.5.5
this paragraph
Citation pattern
…artly repeated in "Of personal identity" and again in the Appendix, invokes Separability (T 1.4.5.5; SBN 233; T 1.4.6.3…
Strawson 20111.4.5.5
this paragraph
Citation pattern
…ethingwhichmayexistbyitself'andhas'noneedofanythingelsetosup port[its]existence'(p.4)(233/1.4.5.5)- thenforallwecankn…
1.4.5.5
this paragraph
Citation pattern
…[experiences].maybeconsider'dasseparatelyex istent,andmayexistseparately',forexample?(233/1.4.5.5) Tosaythatexperien…
1.4.5
T 1.4.5 (42 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…oryofmeaning.33 Bywayoffurtherproof,considertherathercharmingmovehemakesalittle lateronin1.4.5.'Thisgivesmeanoccas…
1.4.5.5
this paragraph
Citation pattern
…taperceiver(a'palpablecontradiction').Hispoint(whichhe makesinseveralotherplaces,e.g. 233/1.4.5.5,244/1.4.5.24,252/§3…
1.4.5
T 1.4.5 (42 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…ofobjectsconstitutesthev eryessenceofcauseandeffect.asfaraswehaveanynotionofthatrelation'(1.4.5 .33/250).Withregard…
1.4.5.5
this paragraph
Citation pattern
…umeholdsboththatwehavenoidea ofsubstanceandthataperception(ofwhichwehavea'perfectidea'234/1.4.5.5)i sasubstance. 250/…
1.4.5
T 1.4.5 (42 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…denteveryperceptionisasub stance,andeverydistinctpartofaperceptionadistinctsubstance'(244/1.4.5. 24).Ittakespractic…
1.4.5.5
this paragraph
Citation pattern
…chIexist,whetheritbeassubstanceo robjectorasaccidentorproperty'(1787:B420).CompareHume233/1.4.5.5.Compa realsoDescart…
1.4.5.5
this paragraph
Citation pattern
…ng.'Descartesdoesn'tatthisstagecommithimselfonthequestionofont ologicalcategory. (88)233/1.4.5.5,635/§19.Humelikesth…
1.4.5
T 1.4.5 (42 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…yandCausation;whicharetheonlybondsthatuniteourt houghtstogether.'. Comparethemovehemakesin1.4.5,discussedonp.50abov…
1.4.5
T 1.4.5 (42 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…hichareplainlyresembling,asimplyingbothofthemanideaoftheobj ect.'(15/1.1.5.8).Inapassagein1.4.5alreadyquoted,hewrit…
1.4.5.5
this paragraph
Citation pattern
…d,relativetothatmisunderstanding,thecomparisonoffersi tselfasargumentativelyneat. See233/1.4.5.5,634/App§12,636/App§…
Inukai 2012T 1.4.5.5
this paragraph
Citation pattern
…nd may exist separately, and have no need of any thing else to support their existence. (T 1.4.5.5, SBN 233) Accordin…
Noonan 2012
focused
THN 1.4.5.5
this paragraph
Citation pattern
…his is the case. Indeed, he thinks that everything which can be conceived is a substance (THN 1.4.5.5 / 233). This is a c…
THN 1.4.5.5
this paragraph
Citation pattern
…stence. They are, therefore, substances, as far as this definition explains a substance. (THN 1.4.5.5 / 233) This argumen…
Pitson 2012T 1.4.5.5
this paragraph
Citation pattern
…g to Strawson, when Hume claims that experiences (or 'perceptions') may exist separately (T 1.4.5.5) he means only that…
Pitson 2013T 1.4.5
T 1.4.5 (42 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
… aspects of the self, those relating to the mind. In "Of the Immateriality of the Soul" (T 1.4.5)-a section which sh…
T 1.4.5.5
this paragraph
Citation pattern
…is applies to whatever may be clearly conceived to exist, including even our perceptions (T 1.4.5.5; SBN 233). But sinc…
T 1.4.5
T 1.4.5 (42 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…tions with that of a substance-in other words, the very view of mind he has criticized in T 1.4.5 as being unintellig…
Cottrell 2015T 1.4.5.5-6, 1
T 1.4.5 (3 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…tion between a mind and its perceptions is that of a substance to its modes or accidents (T 1.4.5.5-6, 1.4.6.3; SBN 233-34, …
SBN 233-34, 252
T 1.4.5.3 to T 1.4.6.4 (8 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…d its perceptions is that of a substance to its modes or accidents (T 1.4.5.5-6, 1.4.6.3; SBN 233-34, 252). Hume rejects each…
SBN 15-16, 17, 27, 232-33
T 1.1.5.6 to T 1.4.5.5 (19 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…a of" and "idea that represents," see, for example, T 1.1.6.1, 1.1.6.3, 1.2.1.3, 1.4.5.3; SBN 15-16, 17, 27, 232-33. ## J ONATHAN COT …
Greco 2015T 1.4.5
T 1.4.5 (42 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
… where Hume's "official theory" of personal identity is commonly found (T 1.4.6, but also T 1.4.5, and then the Appen…
T 1.4.5.5
this paragraph
Citation pattern
…stence. They are, therefore, substances, as far as this definition explains a substance" (T 1.4.5.5/SBN 233). In the li…
Swain 1991Treatise 1.4.5
T 1.4.5 (42 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
… together by the relation of cause and effect."4 Drawing on arguments he had developed in Treatise 1.4.5 and 6, Hume shows i…
Treatise 1.4.5
T 1.4.5 (42 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…,13 but rather to correct the mistaken impression Hume may have given at the beginning of Treatise 1.4.5 ("Of the immaterial…
Loeb 19921.4.5
T 1.4.5 (42 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…ets a number of the nearly synonymous notions not only in 1.3.14, but also at T 246-51 of 1.4.5, and T 632-33 of th…
Spector 19981.4.5
T 1.4.5 (42 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…the entire empirical project to its logical conclusion. 40THN 1.4.4, pp. 225-231. 41THN 1.4.5, pp. 232-251. 42It…
1.4.4-5
T 1.4.4.1 to T 1.4.5.31 n49 (58 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…ation of the concept of identity is especially important with the concept of self. 49THN 1.4.4-5, pp. 225-251. Hume …
THN 1.4.5
T 1.4.5 (42 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…velops a way to answer the odd person in Book II's anatomical account of the passions. 5ITHN 1.4.5, concluding at para…
McIntyre 2003Treatise 1.4.5
T 1.4.5 (42 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…on of the Soul, however, it is surprising that they do not comment on Hume's arguments in Treatise 1.4.5, "Of the immaterial…
Treatise 1.4.5
T 1.4.5 (42 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…dvantage to the materialists above their antagonists" (T 1.4.5.32; SBN 250). Attention to Treatise 1.4.5 shows that prior to…
Ellis 2006
focused
T 1.4.5
T 1.4.5 (42 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
… summarizes arguments Hume lays out earlier in the Treatise, mostly arguments advanced in T 1.4.5. In these two parag…
T 1.4.5
T 1.4.5 (42 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…he self's distinct perceptions together is itself in tension with Hume's earlier claim in T 1.4.5 that the "intellect…
T 1.4.5
T 1.4.5 (42 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…referring to are from two different places in the Treatise. The first is his reasoning in T 1.4.5 that perceptions ar…
T 1.4.5
T 1.4.5 (42 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…lain what actually connects distinct perceptions together is in tension with his claim in T 1.4.5 that the intellectu…
Thiel 2011I.iv.5
T 1.4.5 (42 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…elevance of Book II to his account of personal identity. Other important sections include I.iv.5 on the immaterialit…
I.iv.5
T 1.4.5 (42 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…y and indivisibility of the human soul as substance is dealt with in the previous section I.iv.5 (ibid., p. 242). Th…
I.iv.5
T 1.4.5 (42 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
… I.iv.5 (ibid., p. 242). There, certain 'theologians' are Hume's target. Clearly, section I.iv.5 on immateriality pr…
I.iv.5
T 1.4.5 (42 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…ty is not relevant here; but he does not explain why. It should be obvious, however, from I.iv.5, where he argues th…
Treatise I.iv.5
T 1.4.5 (42 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
… of the mind as a substance is an 'unintelligible' one (ibid.)-a point that Hume makes in Treatise I.iv.5. 'We have no idea o…
I.iv.5
T 1.4.5 (42 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…e, 3 vols. (1898), vol. 1, p. 317. (13) Ibid., p. 323. (14) Ibid., p. 325. For section I.iv.5 and its importance …
I.iv.5
T 1.4.5 (42 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…the Simplicity of the Soul', Hume Studies, 21 (1995), 25-45. For the relationship between I.iv.5 and 6, see 26. See …
I.iv.5
T 1.4.5 (42 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…and Tomaselli (1996), pp. 175-90. As Wright emphasises, referring especially to Treatise, I.iv.5, and the essay 'On …
Strawson 2012THN 1.4.5
T 1.4.5 (42 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…re] in themselves perfectly distinct' (THN 1.4.6.6 / 253). 9 Compare the move he makes in THN 1.4.5 / 232-51, discussed…
Pereira 2014THN I.4.5
T 1.4.5 (42 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
… nutren con consideraciones adicionales que elabora al discutir la idea de sustancia (cf. THN I.4.5; SBN 231). El eleme…
Rocknak 2019T 1.4.5.1-35
T 1.4.5 (35 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…N 225-231) and the notion of an immaterial soul ("Of the immateriality of the soul," i.e. T 1.4.5.1-35; SBN 232-251). Hum…
T 1.4.3-5
T 1.4.3.1 to T 1.4.5.31 n49 (69 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…losophers imagine immaterial soul-objects, ideas of objects are not based on impressions (T 1.4.3-5; SBN 219-251). For …