Treatise Mapping
Map · Book 3: Of Morals · Part 2: Of justice and injustice · T 3.2.11 Of the laws of nations

T 3.2.11.4

SBN 568-9 · cited directly by 2 papers

When men have found by experience, that 'tis impossible to subsist without society, and that 'tis impossible to maintain society, while they give free course to their appetites; so urgent an interest quickly restrains their actions, and imposes an obligation to observe those rules, which we call the laws of justice. This obligation of interest rests not here; but by the necessary course of the passions and sentiments, gives rise to the moral obligation of duty; while we approve of such actions as tend to the peace of society, and disapprove of such as tend to its disturbance. The same natural obligation of interest takes place among independent kingdoms, and gives rise to the same morality; so that no one of ever so corrupt morals will approve of a prince, who volun|tarily, and of his own accord, breaks his word, or violates any treaty. But here we may observe, that tho' the intercourse of different states be advantageous, and even sometimes necessary, yet it is not so necessary nor advantageous as that among individuals, without which 'tis utterly impossible for human nature ever to subsist. Since, therefore, the natural obligation to justice, among different states, is not so strong as among individuals, the moral obligation, which arises from it, must partake of its weakness; and we must necessarily give a greater indulgence to a prince or minister, who deceives another; than to a private gentleman, who breaks his word of honour.

Who cites it

2 of 2 papers cite this paragraph directly; the rest reach it through a page or section range. Snippets are the words around each citation.

PaperCited asContext
Ainslie 1995(T 569)
T 3.2.11 (2 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…t"; the artifices accordingly become less secure, as in the case of international justice (T 569). By the end of the …
(T 569)
T 3.2.11 (2 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
… with members of other societies lessens the need for respect of the artifices of justice (T 569). Why then do we vie…
Garral 2007(T 568-9)
T 3.2.11 (4 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
… where Hume does seem to allow that the strength and force of a moral obligation may vary (T 568-9) or where the extent…
(T 569)
T 3.2.11 (2 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…r just how much can be made from so little. Nor is it clear how talk of duty by "degrees" (T 569) might sit with resp…