T 1.2.5.20
SBN 60-1 · cited directly by 7 papers, reached by 1 more through page or section ranges
When I receiv'd the relations of resemblance, contiguity and causation, as principles of union among ideas, without examining into their causes, 'twas more in prosecution of my first maxim, that we must in the end rest contented with experience, than for want of something specious and plausible, which I might have display'd on that subject. 'Twou'd have been easy to have made an imaginary desectiondissection of the brain, and have shewn, why upon our conception of any idea, the animal spirits run into all the contiguous traces, and rouze up the other ideas, that are related to it. But tho' I have neglected any advantage, which I might have drawn from this topic in explaining the relations of ideas, I am afraid I must here have recourse to it, in order to account for the mistakes that arise from these relations. I shall therefore observe, that as the mind is endow'd with a power of exciting any idea it pleases; whenever it dispatches the |spirits into that region of the brain, in which the idea is plac'd; these spirits always excite the idea, when they run precisely into the proper traces, and rummage that cell, which belongs to the idea. But as their motion is seldom direct, and naturally turns a little to the one side or the other; for this reason the animal spirits, falling into the contiguous traces, present other related ideas in lieu of that which the mind desir'd at first to survey. This change we are not always sensible of; but continuing still the same train of thought, make use of the related idea, which is presented to us, and employ it in our reasoning, as if it were the same with what we demanded. This is the cause of many mistakes and sophisms in philosophy; as will naturally be imagin'd, and as it wou'd be easy to shew, if there was occasion.
Who cites it
7 of 8 papers cite this paragraph directly; the rest reach it through a page or section range. Snippets are the words around each citation.
| Paper | Cited as | Context |
|---|---|---|
| Spector 1998 | 2.3.2.
60 T 1.2.5 (2 paragraphs) Citation pattern | …ot make any difference for the problems of paramnesia, or false memory, as we shall see in 2.3.2. 60Essay 2.27.9, p. 335… |
| Kail 2008 | T 1.2.5.20 this paragraph Citation pattern | …son the animal spirits, falling into the contiguous traces, present other related ideas. (T 1.2.5.20; SBN 60-61) This i… |
| T 1.2.5.20 this paragraph Citation pattern | …(T 1.2.5.20; SBN 60-61) This is the 'cause of many mistakes and sophisms in philosophy' (T 1.2.5.20; SBN 61). Malebranc… | |
| Winkler 2010 | (p. 60) T 1.2.5 (2 paragraphs) Checked by model | …bjects and perceptions, and the difference in their relations, connections, and durations (p. 60), there is, nonethel… |
| Strawson 2011 | 1.2.5.20 this paragraph Citation pattern | …iguoustrace s,presentotherrelatedideasinlieuofthatwhichtheminddesir'datfirsttosurv ey.(60/1.2.5.20) HereHumemakesexpl… |
| 1.2.5.20 this paragraph Citation pattern | …dputtingasidethepointtheHumeactuallytakesitthatallperce ptionsarelocatedinthebrainsee60-1/1.2.5.20andpp.98-9).Thereare… | |
| 1.2.5 T 1.2.5 (30 paragraphs) Citation pattern | …heresomewhere(withaceteri sparibusclausetocoverglitchesinthebrainofthesortdiscussedin60-1/1.2.5. 20),althoughwedon'… | |
| Pitson 2012 | T 1.2.5.20 this paragraph Citation pattern | … and his subsequent account of the part played by brain traces in the relations of ideas (T 1.2.5.20) identifies a categ… |
| Pitson 2013 | T 1.2.5.20 this paragraph Citation pattern | …tion" of the brain which would reveal the role played by traces in the relation of ideas (T 1.2.5.20; SBN 60-61). But in… |
| T 1.2.5.20 this paragraph Citation pattern | … and his subsequent account of the part played by brain traces in the relations of ideas (T 1.2.5.20; SBN 60-61) identif… | |
| Cottrell 2015 | T 1.2.5.20 this paragraph Citation pattern | …d; Hume speculates that this background mechanismmay involve animal spirits in the brain (T 1.2.5.20; SBN 60-61). Given … |
| Loeb 1992 | 1.2.5 T 1.2.5 (30 paragraphs) Citation pattern | … any thing unchangeable be ever said to have duration. (T 37) He returns to the theme in 1.2.5: 226Hume Studies A… |