Treatise Mapping
Map · Book 1: Of the Understanding · Part 2: Of the ideas of space and time · T 1.2.4 Objections answer'd

T 1.2.4.21

SBN 46-7 · cited directly by 5 papers, reached by 3 more through page or section ranges

There are some[11], who pretend, that equality is best defin'd by congruity, and that any two figures are equal, when upon the placing of one upon the other, all their parts correspond to and touch each other. In order to judge of this definition let us consider, that since equality is a relation, it is not, strictly speaking, a property in the figures themselves, but arises merely from the comparison, which the mind makes betwixt them. If it consists, therefore, in this imaginary application and mutual contact of parts, we must at least have a distinct notion of these parts, and must conceive their contact. Now 'tis plain, that in this conception we wou'd run up these parts to the greatest minuteness, which can possibly be conceiv'd; since the contact of large parts wou'd never render the figures equal. But the minutest parts we can conceive are mathematical points; and consequently this standard of equality is the same with that deriv'd from |the equality of the number of points, which we have already determin'd to be a just but an useless standard. We must therefore look to some other quarter for a solution of the present difficulty.

Who cites it

5 of 8 papers cite this paragraph directly; the rest reach it through a page or section range. Snippets are the words around each citation.

PaperCited asContext
Purviance 1997" (46)
T 1.2.4 (3 paragraphs)
Checked by model
…f will be shown, on Hume's view, to be the joint effects of a certain train of perceptions" (46). - 11 Immediately f…
Ellis 2006
focused
T 1.4.2.46
T 1.2.4 (3 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…s between perception and object, one of his primary aims is to criticize the distinction (T 1.4.2.46; SBN 211). Still, …
Strawson 20111.4.2.46
T 1.2.4 (3 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…heother. [3]Theideaofthisrelationisderiv'dfrompastexperience[ofconstantconjunct ion].(212/1.4.2.46) Inthispassageweha…
1.4.2.47
T 1.2.4 (4 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…ationsofexistentialdependenceweknowthat'theexistenceofoneisdependentonthatoftheother'(212/1.4.2.47) -wehavenoempirical…
Noonan 2012
focused
THN 1.4.2.46
T 1.2.4 (3 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…tains all the difficulties of the vulgar system, with others that are peculiar to itself (THN 1.4.2.46 / 211). The second …
Pitson 2013T 1.4.2.46-48
T 1.2.4 (6 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…thstanding his own critical discussion of the philosophical view of a "double existence" (T 1.4.2.46-48; SBN 211-13)-so lon…
Rocknak 2019T 1.4.2.46
T 1.2.4 (3 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…ects; particularly objects that are the continued and distinct causes of our perceptions (T 1.4.2.46; SBN 211). 17 Howe…
T 1.4.2.43-53
T 1.2.4.10 to T 1.2.5.1 (26 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…to the senses," where he discusses the philosopher's rejection of the vulgar perspective (T 1.4.2.43-53; SBN 209-16). Hume'…
Inukai 2007
focused
T 1.4.2.47
T 1.2.4 (4 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…e are certain, are per ceptions, which being immediately present to us by consciousness" (T 1.4.2.47, SBN 212). He divid…
Cottrell 2015T 1.4.2.46 - 55
T 1.2.4.20 to T 1.2.5.5 (19 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…uses of our sensory impressions and attributes the defining properties of a body to them (T 1.4.2.46 - 55; SBN 211 - 17). He …
T 1.4.2.47
T 1.2.4 (4 paragraphs)
Citation pattern
…on cannot support the belief in external objects as "philosophical" people conceive them (T 1.4.2.47; SBN 212), he does …